Economic Strains from Covid 19

Liquid is Key

We are over two months into the crisis in Europe. One thing this has pointed out to me, that I remember when I finished school in Ireland in 2009, at the height of the euro-zone crisis. I looked at a brand new petrol station having the pumps taken away, and over the street next to it, a boarded up coffee shop. It doesn't matter the situation, cash is king! 

A financial crisis is like a heart attack. It hits the pump of the economy hard and the organs, as the blood stops pumping cannot support the body, as they do not have sufficient liquidity. The defibrillator is the central bank, which is the key to getting trust restored and applying the voltage funding to kick start the heart.

A depression on the other hand, is a much more difficult patient. Serious organ failure, complimented with underlying health conditions; a quadruple blowout. There is no clear solution to get this patient out of the coma. More important, is how the economy is sustained during coma and its slow recovery; as it is very easy for the large corporates to eat up their solvent but less liquid competitors.

There are right now, three tiers of balance sheet a business could be.

1. Solid cash generation on hand, few illiquid assets i.e. tech companies.
2. Easy access to capital markets, with a higher cost of financing due to the demand.
3. Cannot access credit and capital impairment probability is high. SMEs and capital-intensive industry.

The final pillar will be the major part of the life support. The ECB and Fed injected over $3 trillion between themselves, with bond buying. However, this is a macro move. Governments have taken their turn in supporting their central banks, but must step in quickly, consistently and effectively, to support the small domestic economy. Caution should be exercised carefully in the aid to large industry, as it could be throwing Semtex at itself or rattling the sabre of next door neighbours. 

Germany is facing serious scrutiny of unfair advantage. As the EU relaxed its law on state aid due to Covid-19, the German ministry filed the largest proportion of state-aid claims to the EU, as it helps to prop up big industries, most notably the airline industry. Though, this has hit hard with less wealthy EU member states left to see their home industries put at a negative advantage.

Cheaper than Water

Being a producer of black gold in 2020 will be remembered as not the best time in the world, being the owner of an empty mine shaft on the other hand.... Oil traders have scoured the globe to find empty Scandinavian salt caves, to unused rail tankers to fill the glutted supply of unwanted crude.

In late April, Brent fell below zero from the mid-seventies in value of long-ago January, for the first time in history, causing an interesting phenomenon of a contango. As the spot price fell below zero, future prices overtook in value. Traders had the unique ability to buy and sell back deliveries on the futures market at a reasonable profit complimenting an additional surge in storage demand.

Cheap oil has the incentive of attracting a quicker rebound to the global economy. However, this comes with its downside when too low. OPEC is seen sometimes as a group of spoilt children, fighting over the lion’s share of production. But it plays an important stabilisation role of its members economies. Rural communities in Nigeria are highly dependant on the sale of oil as a source of income, as are most mid-African and middle eastern nations. However, with values not expected to go up anytime soon to break-even levels, civil unrest will be highly probable, even with OPEC cuts.

It would not be a far stretch to think additionally the oil crash was not intentional. It is well versed the Russian-Saudi annoyance towards the young shale and fracking industry in the US, which commands a higher break-even price and is not state supported, thus leaving room to quickly shock the unprotected industry, before slowing the pumps.

Closing remarks with a Gothic upswing

There will be a lot more debt in society, and a stronger desire of companies to look at resilience before efficiency, as a global supply chain can only be efficient if effective.

The rewiring of supply chains away from the inter-dependence of global health will be a major step, already in process. The epidemic in some ways may have triggered an inevitability, as US-China trade tensions from 2019 linger on and the crumbling of the EU collective continues its course.

It would not be a far reaching thought to see a pre Great Depression scenario, whereby the cost of goods and services increases, as well as barriers to entry for international trade, through taxes and tariffs for the protection of home industry. This will deeply stimulate cost push and demand pull inflation. Though, with the technological overview to monitor the economy and global cooperative approaches in the 21st century, it could create a balancing in the distribution of wealth to domestic economies, to the lower income earners. This would occur, as new employment is created locally and low skilled labour is required, leading to social policies winning greater favour in local government institutions, perhaps in the mid-term to incentivise the demand for labour.

Macroeconomic Pathogens

As Andrew Bailey warms up to his new office as governor of the Bank of England, he has a weather pattern that doesn’t sit well. He must wield the hand of a strained monetary policy in an upcoming Brexit world, and look to his fellow BoE economists in the impact modelling of Covid-19 on the UK. He knows the effectiveness of his institution is being tested, and as the rain pours down on thread needle street, the Dow Jones Level - 1 circuit breaker is hit.

Level 1: A drop of 7% from the prior day's closing price of the S&P 500 triggers a 15-minute trading halt. Trading is not halted if the drop occurs at or after 3:25 p.m. ET.

Level 2: A drop of 13% triggers a 15-minute halt. Trading is not halted if the drop occurs at or after 3:25 p.m. ET.

Level 3: A drop of 20% triggers a halt for the rest of the trading day, and trading resumes the following day.

Viruses and the economy

A pandemic is an interesting economic scenario, because it really has an open rule book to how it behaves, depending on the origin. It typically hits supply first, instead of demand. No matter how high the want for Parmesan cheese may be. A closed factory with a quarantined workforce in Italy will not meet the consumer demand. Take this with the additional pressure from panic buying, and we have an inverse relationship occurring.

In December, in a small district in the city of Wuhan, China. A local food market formulated, under the correct conditions Covid-19 that became the kick-starter to the correction of the world economy and largest global pathogenic outbreak in the industrialised world. Covid-19 has taken advantage of our interdependent infrastructure and supply chain. Bringing the economic might of China to a halt, and has now spread beyond borders and across the globe. Now with halted production, the dynamic borrowing small & medium enterprises in China depend on are becoming the first economic casualties.

Troubled water for the fishes

March was always going to be a difficult month. Fragile OPEC talks took place whereby leading oil producing states turned hostile in talks. Already having to deal with an economic slowdown from the virus, led to a terrible disagreement on supply cuts in order to combat the decline in oil receipts. This combined with negative data ensuing from the previous week, made markets on the 9^th of March hit the circuit breakers on US indices.

What further impact will be felt, is still early days, however these corrections will turn the portfolio manager to dive deeper into their folder and see which institutions and corporations are weak on the cash side and are “zombies” to this economic stagnation.

Airlines usually are the first ones with blood in the water and will be an interesting case with the crippled airline manufacturing issues from Boeing. However, they are hit in two ways. A reduction in sales, though also a reduction in fuel costs as now Jet fuel futures turn cheap. Yet, sales will take precedent, in combination to employee costs from the Covid-19 impact. March is the main month that fills the balance sheet and with the high ratios of the industry of net debt to Ebitda, the sharks will be circling for the bite.

Passing of the Baton to Fiscal

The last ten years has seen the largest global injection of cash into financial markets, with central banks fighting the faults of a stalling global economy. Yet, there are some human elements central bankers cannot solve, and where politicians will have no choice but to step up, as monetary policy shows its limit.

Government bonds took up the majority of the capital flight as US and European notes hit historic highs and as the fed made an emergency cut of 50 basis points, the central bankers of the world reaffirmed their position. Fiscal policy needs to step to the plate. 

Despite these warnings for many years, few economies are willing or able to act. The US congress passed a $8bn emergency corona virus response bill, to help struggling industries, though the euro-zone's export animal Germany needs to act fast, and reduce it's bickering on the purse string to the €1tn budget for the euro-zone. Despite having year-on-year fiscal surpluses Berlin has yet to relieve the several quarters of weak growth to fiscal policy. 

Closing remarks

After some further debating, OPEC will reach an agreement after their economies woo on sentiment. Yet, depending on the global fiscal response to small and medium sized industries, the a short lived bear could be an underestimation.

This brings me to my most beloved index. The VIX made it's comeback from the volatility and mania of 2008 on Monday, and acts as a careful reminder to governments and institutions, of the many weak spots the economy still has, if left unbalanced.

Making the Markets; Inflation with a vengence

Today not only marks my return to the blog; but the real start of Brexit, as English stomachs begin vomiting economic downfall in their own borders.
I returned to my opinion column, as what any goth can tell you they are good at, feeling bad things are about to happen.

Inflation & Abenomics

The regressive move of initiating article 50, will effect growth. However let us not forget about growth's eviler more volatile brother; Inflation. For the last decade this chap has been really quiet. In some cases such as Japan, they are doing their upmost to increase it. The so called complexity of Abenomics aka the John Maynard Keynes Hybrid.

• For Abenomics to succeed, Japanese consumers will need to reverse  deflationary forces of excess saving and encourage an increased propensity of consumption.
• Age: the unsustainable ratio of the elderly to the working population, fallout should fiscal stimulus fail, and snowballing costs for imports.
• Abe’s structural reforms carry with them several risks. The domestic agriculture sector could suffer from increased marketplace competition should tariffs on imports be removed.
• Any agreements with the TPP would mean greater dependency on government support among Japanese farmers, adding a further load on finances.

But the characteristic of inflation can be very underestimated. Primarily it's effect on domestic trade, especially in protectionist countries. I.E. The soon to be USA & UK.

Great Depression background

The last time a developed country experienced inflationary issues due to protectionism mixed in with specialisation, was the time of the great depression. Domestic growth was steadily increasing, as was full employment. Though the balance of payments of the United states was terrible, as well as domestic borrowing. Eventually leading to over production, due to trade barriers eliminating any trade advantage being exported, leading to the value of USD dropping and the cost of living increasing until the fatal Black Tuesday.

The Human reasoning

Behavioural economics shows a desire of more inward looking domestic buying, and the likelihood of imports been desired decreasing, due to political & social thought. Yet the knock on effect is a reduced import volume, at the same a reduced desired to employ necessary labour to foreigners, where the greatest supply to meet the demand is found for less desired roles.

With what people around Europe and North America are believing in as a necessary solution to fight globalisation is to bar immigrants and Refugees from crossing their borders. I can understand their frustration. Yet, on a 21st century political wheel and democratic legislation and time consumption being in place, this position of thought, is a very dangerous one for setting off the demon of inflation.

The Diabetic shock

Combine the GDP demon with the perceived cost of borrowing and its desire to increase, however still artificially low, to keep the economy fat. If an obesity bubble kicks off. Hiking rates, is like giving the fat man no more sugar and tons of insulation. Eventually he will have no more sugar to keep him alive. We can see that the US Fed is letting the man off the sugar, as inflation is making itself. Part of the advantage when comparing now to black Tuesday, is the fact the Central Banks are prepared to combat it, where as in 1929 they stood by and watched

Super Summer, Super Thursday, Black Monday & End of Brazil's Commodity Cycle

Thursday the 6th of August signalled no change in Bank of England’s interest rate (Currently 0.5%), China’s central bank getting ready to move its weight in the direction of returning to devaluation, in order to boost exports, and from the other side of the Pacific, the looks of the US dollar strength year on year 20% bringing thoughts on the soon to be basis rate increase by the Federal Reserve.

S&P 500 Turmoil 

The major topics to be highlighted here are miscommunication and fundamental problems in the announcement of Central banks in the recent affairs of August.

Carney’s MPC

When double the information is released, as well as Mark Carney’s patented monetary trick of forward guidance, a market feels more reassured.

An 8-1 vote amongst the MPC committee, reaffirmed the near whole agreement of the current state of inflation targeting. Not only was the move concrete, it marked also the strength of the Canadian central banker’s hold at sailing the market through unknown hotspots arising.

The Forward guidance Mark Carney delivered was however the thought of many analysts; the UK economy is ‘in need in care’. The absolute truth and gut feeling for the majority, after an interesting summer change in growth levels, they know things could soon spike like a thunderbolt from the heavens, right down to the ground.

Reasons?

Most greatly mentioned is falling commodity prices, leading to lower inflation, also the continuing unknown course within the Euro-zone area, Russia and the slowdown in growth within the Far East and emerging economies. Hopefully due to this Carney could hopefully see the weighing scales to dip on either of the following two.

•  Most consumers will decide to save, increasing MPS,
• Consumers will be driven to consume more, due to the fall in production, fall in commodity prices, the price of goods will become less, keeping inflation positive.

As much as the second will help GDP, the first is more of a key issue, when it comes to either stagnation or end of the growth cycle.

Far East Volatility

Last week has been quite the roller coaster ride as Asian Stocks bore a significant plunge in value on Monday, then making a deep recovery by Thursday; Is this the end of Chinese volatility?

Vix Volatility Index S&P 500 

At the beginning of August, The Peoples Bank of China conducted devaluation of their international yuan currency, in order to help boost exports to deal with the crash in the Chinese markets. Though the delivery of the information was poor. The sudden unexpected change in the exchange rate policy, led to market turmoil that only calmed after clarification by the PBOC.

“China will maintain economic operations within a reasonable range”

The initial feel by the markets led to a global selloff of risky assets, as they believed it was a reaction to the abrupt deterioration in Chinese growth.

In the following days, China clarified the message by ensuring that the move they had made in devaluation was designed to

“Enhance market-orientation and benchmark status”.

The acknowledgement of poor communication had the effect of calming the markets, as the above statement gave light to moves the PBOC had made. First their purchasing of currency, the knowledge of $3.6Tr USD being in reserve, as well as US federal reserve rate hikes being on the  horizon soon enough. Domestically also the Renminbi’s real exchange rate has appreciated >25% since 2007.

Forecast

The gut feeling of analysts and my own personal assumptions, are that we can expect a steady slowdown in Chinese growth. This of course, leading to weaker demand in commodities, thereby having a knock-on effect on the Australian economy. At the end meaning, that portfolio diversification is crucial and that we should expect more surprises from China, as they grapple to deal with a crucial situation with their economy.

Economic Forecast: The Weather in Rio is looking bleak

For the body of Christ that towers over Rio, the Brazilian government also sees the world looking down. The country faces the end of its commodity growth cycle; and if that was not enough huge corruption, declining consumer confidence and preparation towards the Olympic Games.

Due to the rise in supply of oil, slowdown in emerging market production levels, and weak capital markets, Brazil is facing a dire position. The major fall of the Petrobas scandal, in its corruption and rescue cost to the economy, has only contributed more to the slowdown in economic growth and widening of the Brazilian deficit.

The situation, began by Brazil revaluating its surplus targets that sparked a selloff of Brazilian assets. Soon enough it led to an announcement by Standard & Poors, warning of the investment status being downgraded.

Brazil is desperately trying to take control of its inflation. In the last seven meetings of Brazil’s central bank, there has been an increase in interest rates each time, which now stands at 14.25%. Coupled together with two consecutive quarters of declining GDP, South America’s largest economy is now in recession.

The Gothic Economist's Referendum view

So here is my last view of the referendum, I would like to say that in all of my posts or comments on the Scottish vote, they have all been taken from an economic & behavioural viewpoint.

The Currency

The UK will not enter a monetary union with Scotland regardless of the debt levels, due to the fact it gives a major error to the UK economy’s currency fluctuations. Also the Scottish economy will have to devalue itself to become competitive. Establish trade agreements which we have no knowledge of, seeing as Scotland’s requirements for EU membership do not exist is a big risk, and puts Scotland in unknown territory.

The major issue is that if there is no currency union or even if there was, the deposits of every bank account in Scotland would no longer be guaranteed by the Bank of England.

So we can assume a new currency will be established and will most likely be a pegged mechanism, that will see a central bank created with its own monetary policy. However this peg will require reserves of more than 40 Bn GBP, in order to defend any currency attack. If it were to be mature and stable the Hong Kong equivalent is 135 Bn GBP.

The local economy

For those people who feel Scotland will thrive within 3 years, will be sincerely disappointed and of course the UK will be worse off without Scotland, because Scotland is bringing down their economy. Which investor in their right mind desires to keep their assets in an area where uncertainty is high, and that losses deem to be most certain.

Companies are scaring the Scottish public,and this is for a reason. It is that bad and these companies will be heavily taxed. They may still operate in Scotland but they will not mind becoming more tax avoidant, as it will cost less. Thus the Scottish economy will be relying more on income tax. Austerity will have to occur in the first year and the Scottish government would have to go to the money markets, though the money markets are highly unlikely to be friendly in the first 5 years.

Oil & current world economic cycle

There are a few major issues with the commodities side. Oil is a great thing, but bear in mind if your currency does not hold large reserves... If an oil spike were to occur (which many economists will see as being certain as gravity this winter), Scotland will have serious problems. Especially as we are about to enter another recessive phase in the growth cycle. I take this as it can already be seen from slowdowns in Chinese growth.

Chinese Economic seriousness

China is looking more by every month of turning into a Japanese economic cycle. The fear behind this is, is that is the debt burden http://time.com/3332552/china-japan-economic-crisis/ . What is more troubling is the heavy value the Bank of China have in US Treasury Securities which they may sell, even more so now for Geo-Economic strategy.

The UK Economy

The UK will be a separate country, whose obligations are to help its own UK citizens and will rightfully do so. However Scotland will be a foreign country and it will take some time to establish itself as a working economy, and the UK will have its own problems to think about, due to the serious loss of assets and investment which will have occurred. Nearly 1 Billion GBP left the economy last week, just due to the referendum.

The Geo political economic world.

From my previous post, the world looks like it is entering the brink again, thus for a new economy to prosper from this is looking rather doubtful.

The Scottish Currency and Putin Economics

The week beginning was marked with Russia forcing aid into rebel held eastern Ukraine and the Second debate on Scottish independence from the United Kingdom.

Alex Salmond a bachelor of Economics and History, that went on to be leader of the Scottish National Party went against former Chancellor of the Exchequer Alistair Darling in a Televised debate on Monday night.

The debate, was a battle of words, with no answers for many on analysing and interpreting the outcome of Scotland's economy. The major being the currency. Alex Salmond fended off the question, though to many researchers and analysts the answer is a separate diluted currency. With this answer assumed as the most logical for an independent Scottish economy to function, let a alone work, the creation of a currency is inevitable.

The major issue en-laced within the UK government's need is that all UK debt is embedded in valuations of assets, such as assets in Scotland. This would in turn affect the borrowing capabilities and pricing for the remainder of the UK. Though the same would be for Scotland, the Scottish economy would have undertake its share of the debt produced from toxic assets incurred within the financial crisis. This in itself will cause capital flight to likely occur.

How to get the debt from Scotland is more of a major issue that the UK has to figure out, and will markets react to an unsound Scottish balance of payments book? With the quick decision making of the financial markets, and how to justify the information, the risk is acute.


Russia's economy is set for a strong downturn with the economic sanctions taking a deep toll on the balance of payments. Vladimir's game strategy back in march, was very successful as the economic sanctions over Russian influence on Crimea would have lifted and Russian territory would have expanded. It was a great strategic move as the markets saw their financial power see no change in the political strategy of the Kremlin. Though we are nearing September, and long term sanctions are not favourable. Even for a low rouble.

Though with low economic growth for Russia, will it be likely that Putin, takes a more aggressive stance in the Ukraine Crisis? After heightening the tensions with Kiev after sending a large convoy of "Aid" supplies into the rebel stronghold, Russian provocation of the west is becoming less forward strategy.Though a lot of moves made by the Russian premier in March were new out of the rule book.

Looking at the soft and hard currency position. Many companies from and working within Russia,are finding it next to impossible for day to day transactions to be conducted in the Russian Rouble. The oil and gas sector is heavily dependant on outside technology and skills, a major area the economic sanctions are effecting. Companies such as BP who own a major majority of Rosneft(Russian national oil company), are left being unable to transfer income to the UK subsidiaries or supply their projects.

From an investing point of view for game strategy, the likelihood of an escalation occurring even more is inapt. Conciliation of Russia and Ukraine, in order for the easing of economic sanctions is greater probability. However with multiple fields of major medical, civil and political unrest around the continental plate, there is greater chance of the less probable decision occurring, as with widespread risk, there is a greater prospect to get away with more.

Stormy seas ahead G.E.

A Russian Trade Union, a love story with Ukraine

An interesting new political strategy is happening in Eastern Europe and on the north Asian plateau and it all smells too much like strategic economics again. Russia is moving its economic weight, but this time for a new strategic move of geographic proportion, an expansion into the realm of the trade/Customs union.

The EU is not only a unity of policies, with endless bilateral agreements and an entanglement of laws. Its main function at the end, is primarily to liberalise the movement of free trade within the European countries, which we closely now refer to as member states.

The reason to join a customs/trade union are simple, export growth that can lead a much better balanced current account for a country. Germany currently being the most prosperous, and even more so since the European Monetary Union was introduced, has led the way in showing how free trade is a great source for GDP.

Russia is currently focusing on expanding its customs union to the former USSR satellite states and then maybe further onto the Eurasian plate. It wants to take advantage of its natural resource position and the export dependency a lot of the former satellite states still have on it.

Ukraine was poised and ready to become a member state of the European Union, though it all smells now like a large bluff.  At the end of it all, it comes down to your largest trading partner. Ukraine does its trade with Russia a significant amount more than with the EU. Having then a bilateral agreement between the two, would significantly reduce export/import costs. Also most Ukrainians feel more Russian than European in culture, one thing resented by many of the eastern bloc is the European unity and fear of culture loss.

 

 

  (Click to enlarge image)




 

Though behind these arguments lies the main reason. Russia has always dominated the energy supply of the eastern European sector, and Ukraine knows this too well. Vladimir Putin has also imposed heavy custom checks on Ukrainian imports creating losses in the billions in theory. Embargoes from chocolate to steel pipes were also imposed upon goods this year and Mr Putin goes further on this, with forwardly stating that the Customs union as a whole may impose high levies in order to protect the Union for EU goods possibly entering their market.

The Payoff for Russia is vast. Not only does it secure a competitive advantage of trade with the Ukraine and cuts off basically its trade relations with the EU. It further tightens its power over the former soviet state and overall makes it ever so more dependent on Russia.

Vladimir Putin is also winning powerful game with the EU over its diplomatic procedure. That in all the EUs democratic ways are rather pointless in competitive arguments, as even if the Ukraine in someways would prefer to be courting itself with the EU commission, it still has to get into bed with Moscow. But this is by far not the first major hit by Russian Bear: slowly but surely it is geographically taking back its land.

It is amazing the unfortunate though inevitable power that strategic reason can have in undemocratic environments, but it is a good example of how maybe technocratic procedures could eliminate these problems for the EU, as it battles several fronts. Banking unity, Soverigen debt restructuring, migrational issues and strategic economics.

Tata for now
G.E.